Moving Beyond Electrospinning: Melt Nanofiber Production

Nanofibers have long shown great promise for advancing textile and material performance in
applications ranging from air and liquid filtration to battery separators, to sound insulation and
fluid barriers in hygiene products. For example, in filtration, nanofibers have been shown
theoretically cellular matrix that enables the propagation of living cells for wound care and
tissue engineering. These fibers, generally described in commercial settings as having diameters of
less than 1 micron, have been the subject of intensive study for quite some time. Indeed, a
literature review reveals an extensive field of research and the reporting of performance
improvements. One is hard-pressed to find a university that does not have a makeshift
electrospinning needle that is being used to demonstrate the advances in material performance that
occur at the nanoscale. Academia has applied great diligence in characterizing and reporting these
findings. Furthermore, a patent search quickly reveals that many of the largest nonwovens,
filtration and textile companies in the world have not only performed extensive R&D in this
area, but have also made significant investments in protecting their positions.


However, it is clear that the commercialization of the total potential of nanofiber
technology has yet to be realized. In 2010, United States-based BCC Research LLC estimated that the
entire market for nanofiber products would reach approximately $183 million in 2012. In comparison,
microfiber production today totals several billions of dollars annually and growing rapidly,
according to International Nonwovens Consulting, United States. However, Donaldson Filtration Co.
Inc., also based in the United States, began pioneering nanofiber filters in the mid- to late
1980s. This was not long after meltblown microfibers began to make their way to the end market, and
Reicofil spunbond-meltblown-spunbond (SMS) lines began to proliferate. In evaluating the driver
behind this divergence, one must look at the differences between melt-based processes and
solvent-intensive processes such as electrospinning. Indeed, the primary challenge in scaling
electrospinning has been the high solvent-to-polymer concentrations needed to produce the
nanofiber. More solvents lead to lower yields, dramatically increased operating expense and an
environmental burden that is counter to the vast sustainability efforts underway in most nonwovens
and textile companies. Indeed, research is underway to develop melt-based electrospinning. At a
recent conference in Japan, several leading electrospinning companies reported on the work they
have done in this area, but the data clearly demonstrated that significant challenges exist in
converting electrospinning to a melt-based process.

In an effort to finally begin to transfer the full potential of nanofiber technology to end
products, leading materials companies have addressed the challenges of productivity, profitability
and environmental responsibility by acquiring melt-based processes as the platforms they will
leverage into the future. This effort has initiated a new era beyond electrospinning that is
focused on melt nanofiber production technology. This article presents two process platforms that
exist today, the materials that are available in fiber form, the near-term markets for end
applications and the endless possibilities that are created when there is an unlimited availability
of nanofibers.

Melt Nanofiber Processes

Meltblown is a one-step process in which high-velocity heated air blows a molten
thermoplastic resin from an extruder die tip onto a conveyor or take-up screen to create fibers.
Originally developed in its commercial form at Exxon in the late 1970s, meltblown has proven very
useful for making fibers with diameters in the range of tens of microns and higher, but the focus
of most of the development of this technology has been toward higher line speeds and integration
into spunbond lines. Recently, the effort has shifted away from higher-volume production and toward
finer fiber for advanced air filtration performance. Research conducted in Germany and the United
States has been focused almost solely on polypropylene (PP) and has shown gains in generating
fibers in the submicron range. The challenges faced in driving fiber diameter lower include the
importance of increasing the air-to-polymer mass flux ratio. This higher ratio leads to a need for
very high air velocities and limited polymer feed rates that increase operating costs and limit
productivity. Another challenge is the broad distribution of fiber diameters that can significantly
impact air filtration performance.


Melt nanofiber technologies include meltblown technology (above), diagram courtesy Atul
Dahiya, “Meltblown Technology”; and Forcespinning® technology (below), diagram courtesy of FibeRio
Technology Corp.


Recently, work has expanded beyond PP with gains being made by a research group at The
University of Tennessee in processing polylactic acid (PLA) nanofibers. PLA is coveted as an
eco-friendly thermoplastic with beneficial material performance. As work in meltblown continues to
expand into new materials, applications will increase as well.

Forcespinning® technology uses centrifugal force to process materials into
nanofiber. A spinneret cup is rotated at high speeds to initiate hydrostatic and shear forces that
push a liquid material, either melt or solution, though orifices lining the outer wall of a
spinneret. As the material enters the orifice chamber, molecules disentangle and then align
directionally to form nanofibers. This unique technology has only recently been developed to
commercial-level production by FibeRio Technology Corp., United States, and it has already gained
significant momentum with reporting of PP nanofibers with average diameters of less than 500
nanometers (nm). Furthermore, a 100-fold increase in productivity rate has enabled the technology
to be viewed for more than air filtration applications. Dramatic productivity gains have been
demonstrated with both the melt-based process and solution spinning via higher polymer
concentration levels than electrospinning.

Other materials that have been melt-spun include PLA, polybutylene terephthalate (PBT),
polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polyamides (PA), polyvinylidine fluoride, low-molecular-weight
polyethylene and thermoplastic polyurethane. The applications thereof are incredibly broad, ranging
from performance apparel to fuel filtration and more. However, the full potential of Forcespinning
technology will emerge as FibeRio sets its sites on melt processing engineered plastics into


The use of melt-based production processes will expand the use of nanofibers for air
filtration applications.

Melt-spun Nanofiber Applications

Medical Nonwovens: Global Industry Analysts Inc., United States, estimates that
the global disposable medical nonwovens market will reach US$20.9 billion by 2017. Applications in
this area include surgical gowns, drapes and tray covers. Melt-spun PP nanofibers can be utilized
to provide the breathable barrier performance required for these products.

In the past year, FibeRio reported significant water-barrier performance improvements with
almost 60 millibar of hydrostatic head – a value compliant with Level 3 of the Association for the
Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) PB70 standard – with only 6 grams per square meter
(gm2) of material compared to the traditional 15 gm2 of material from meltblown microfibers, making
the fabric lightweight and breathable through the use of nanofiber media.

Filtration: Nanofibers have been used for quite some time in air filtration
applications. However, the use of melt-based processes will expand their use in that market.
Melt-spun PP nanofiber from both meltblown and Forcespinning technology have demonstrated high
efficiency ratings with low pressure drop. The efficiency ratings are driven by the utilization of
Brownian Diffusion, while the pressure drop performance can be attributed to slip flow at the
surface of the fiber. These benefits create a significant opportunity for many filtration companies
because regulatory bodies recently have moved to eliminate the historical practice of
electrostatically charging the media to achieve high efficiency ratings as demonstrated by the new
European standard EN779:2012.

However, as fiber diameters continue to decrease, new applications such as water filtration
become available. Significant opportunities are created using melt-spun PP and PET nanofibers to
achieve pore sizes comparable to those of membranes while providing the lower pressure drop of a
fibrous media. Additionally, PBT nanofibers can be used in fuel filtration and blood separation

Performance Apparel: Recently, nanofibers have found their way into end products
such as socks, jackets and even golf gloves. Materials have varied from PA 6 to PET. It is believed
that these processes were solvent-based, and it would stand to reason that the emergence of
melt-spun PET nanofibers, with higher annual capacities and lower operating expenses, could
substantially increase the use of nanofibers in these applications.

Wound Care: Management of moisture is driven by control over porosity, which is why
nanofibers have emerged as a critical tool in the wound-care industry. Furthermore, materials must
be at the very least biocompatible, and preferably, in some cases, bioresorbable. In these
instances, toxic residue from solvents are a nonstarter and limit commercial opportunities.
Melt-spun PLA nanofibers and, in the future, melt-spun polycaprolactone fibers overcome this
challenge while simultaneously increasing productivity.

Acoustic Insulation
: Environmental awareness and rising costs of fuel have driven
the term “light-weighting” to the forefront of automotive and aerospace transportation lexicons. In
this regard, nanofibers enable automotive suppliers to substantially reduce material weights while
improving acoustic insulation performance. The challenge until now has been the cost sensitivity
and high volumes of such an industry. However, melt-spun nanofiber overcomes that challenge, and PP
and PET are resins that are already familiar to the industry.


Nanofiber applications for medical nonwovens include disposable surgical gowns, drapes and
tray covers.

Future Directions

As the range of materials broadens, another area being eval-uated is the use of nano-fibers
in dispersions and as reinforcements in composites. Nanoscale fibers are capable of even
distribution in a polymer matrix and hold great promise for improving tear strength, regulating
viscosity and improving other properties. Staple nanofibers are just beginning to be considered by
materials engineers and could have vast applications far beyond composite reinforcement.
Cost-effective volume manufacturing will enable these applications to become commercially viable.

Other markets that will come online as melt nanofiber processing achieves productivity and
line speed scale-up will be applications in hygiene nonwovens. As private label suppliers continue
to take market share, branded product suppliers are searching for new paths to differentiation.
This development has led to a search for technologies that provide thinner materials and enhance
fluid management capability.

Efforts in meltblown and Forcespinning technology are removing productivity, operating
expense and environmental barriers. As final hurdles to high-volume nanofiber production are
overcome, the conversation will shift away from process challenges and toward new end-product
development and intellectual property required to compete. The future of nanofibers is primed for
any applications that are looking for ways to reduce weight while

improving material performance. Melt processing also enables the use of new, greener
materials for existing applications. Furthermore, novel capabilities are enabled through the use of
new materials such as aromatics, sulfones, fluoropolymers and urethanes. Already, these materials
have demonstrated great promise at the research level, and new developments will rapidly scale them
to continuous industrial production.

Bryce W. Davis, Ph.D., is materials engineer, and Kial Gramley is vice president,marketing and
business development, FibeRio Technology Corp.

January/February/March 2013